Cook the Cover – How Rachael Ray Made Me Hate Baking

So after doing a pretty darn good job cooking the cover of Bon Appetit, I declared my next cook the cover to be the June issue of Rachael Ray Every Day.  I knew that whatever dish was on the cover, it was going to be full of flavor and yum-o.    The June issue arrived, and being a sweet-lover, I was happy to see the ice cream tacos.  Ice cream tacos! I can make them, no problem!  But, it wasn’t quite as easy as it looked.  Not even close to easy.

I read through the recipe and thought that making the actual taco shells wasn’t going to be all that easy.  Maybe we could substitute some Ortega shells, I thought?  Maybe not.  So I put off making them, until it had to be done.  Here’s how it went:

Making the Ice Cream Tacos

taco shell ingredients

I had all of the ingredients on hand! I like that in a recipe!

The kids helped me make the tacos, so it’s always easier when the ingredients are measured out and ready to go.  (Mise en place right? Which also means a lot of extra dishes to wash).

The batter was pretty quick to make.  It tasted and looked like brownie batter.  We’re off to a good start.

We swirled the batter into the correct size (5″, yes I had the ruler out) and put them in the oven. Two shells are baked at a time, so the recipe takes awhile to prepare.  You can’t really bake more than two at a time because you have to curl the shells pretty quickly after they come out of the oven.  Oh, how I just love running the oven on a hot summer day.

Cocoa taco shells

Two shells going in the oven. Make sure the edges aren’t too thin or they’ll burn.

The recipe instructs you to set up a taco-making station.  Make sure you have this ready to go before the first shells come out of the oven.  Here’s our taco-making station in action:

Forming the taco shell

Boxes, paper towel tubes and parchment. I wonder if this is how they make tacos in Mexico?

I have to say, forming the shells was the worst part (of my life).  My recipe made seven shells and three of them broke!  Having the shells in between two sheets of parchment, and then hanging them on the paper towel tube was slippery.  They fell right off the tube.  There’s nothing worse than not even being in the kitchen and hearing a taco shell crash and shatter onto the counter.  I would have liked to seen Rachael Ray do this successfully.  (Side note:  I wonder if they have normal bakers test their recipes?  I’d offer, just so there are no tacos involved.)

To remedy this, I trimmed the parchment paper so it was just a bit bigger than the shells.  I also put the second sheet of parchment on top of the baked shell and then put it on the tube.  It worked good enough.  Of course, we didn’t throw the broken shells away…

After the shells cooled, they were dipped in the chocolate sauce and pecans or pistachios.  Please don’t think this step was easy, because we are now treating these taco shells like Dale Chihuly glass sculptures and trying our hardest to not break anymore!

In the end, I made one dulce de leche taco and one with vanilla bean ice cream topped with strawberries and chocolate sauce.

The Final Result

Caramel and strawberry ice cream tacos

Ice cream tacos, a food first for us!

The tacos are definitely a feast for the eyes! I love food that is so colorful and pretty!  I’ll just keep the misery of making them a secret.

Eating tacos is generally a mess right?  Well, these didn’t disappoint.  Melting ice cream, sticky sauce and crumbly taco shells is a messy combination.  That didn’t stop us though!

The ice cream tacos tasted very good, were a mess to eat, and a disaster to make.  Whew!  Glad this is over!

Cook the Cover Rachael Ray Every Day

The results of June’s Cook the Cover!

The Cook the Cover Challenge

This monthly cook the cover challenge is fun in so many ways.  First there is the element of surprise, because you don’t know what you are going to be making.  Then, you have to read the recipe and take on the challenge of a possible new cooking technique or maybe you get to try a new ingredient or two.  Finally, you get the satisfaction of the final meal and knowing that yes, you are a pretty darn good cook!

Next Month’s Cook the Cover

For next month’s cook the cover, I’m going to cook whatever is on the cover of the July issue of Food Network Magazine.  I challenge you to do the same.  I’m sure we’ll be preparing something fresh and perfect for summer. Let’s hope the recipe isn’t by Rachael Ray.  I can’t wait!

cook the cover everyday Rachael Ray

No Comments

Leave a Comment